How to Choose a Candle Wick for Natural Wax

Rows of freshly poured white candles seen from above

The wick decides how a candle burns. This guide covers what a wick does, the wick families makers use with natural waxes, how wax hardness and vessel width change the size you need, and a burn test to confirm your choice.

What a wick does

A wick works like a pump. It pulls melted wax up to the flame, where the wax burns. The flame melts the wax around it, and that melt pool is the fuel. The National Candle Association has a short overview of candle wicks.

Wick size sets how much fuel reaches the flame. A larger wick delivers more wax, which makes a bigger flame, more heat and a wider, deeper melt pool. The goal is a flame large enough to melt the wax across the vessel and no larger.

Wax type, candle size and shape, color and scent all influence the choice, so every wick recommendation is tied to one specific candle.

The main wick families

Flat braided cotton with paper (CD and ECO)

These are the series most makers start with in natural wax containers. Both are flat cotton braids with paper threads woven in, which stiffens the wick so it stands up without a core.

The CD series is generally chosen for softer, thicker natural waxes and for more heavily scented candles. The ECO series is generally chosen for soy and blended waxes, and it comes in fewer sizes. Those are the uses each series is sold for, so let your own burn test confirm the choice.

Cored wicks

A cored wick is braided or knitted around a center that keeps it upright while it burns. Cotton and paper are common core materials, and cored wicks are used in jar candles, pillars and votives.

Wood wicks

Wood wicks are thin strips of wood held in a metal clip. Makers choose them for the look of the flame and a soft crackling sound.

They are trimmed shorter. Trim a wood wick to 1/8 to 3/16 inch (3 to 5 mm), against 1/4 inch (6 mm) for cotton, because wax cannot climb a wood wick that is left too long.

Why soft waxes need a different size

Two properties matter most. Melt point sets how much heat the wax needs, and viscosity sets how easily the liquid wax travels up the wick.

A wax with a high melting point may need a larger wick than the chart suggests. A wax with a low melting point may need a smaller one.

Coconut blends sit at the soft end. They generally need a smaller wick than soy wax, because the thinner liquid wax moves through the wick faster and gives a similar melt pool from a smaller flame.

Our Creamy Coconut Wax (CCN1 by Calwax) has a melting point of 108 to 115°F (42 to 46°C), so expect to test on the smaller side of a chart written for soy. If you firm it up with beeswax or rice bran wax, as covered in how to harden coconut wax, the blend needs more heat and the wick may need to go back up.

Vessel diameter sets the starting size

One wick has to melt wax from the center out to the wall, so the wider the vessel, the larger the wick. Measure the inside diameter at the widest point the wax will reach.

Within a series, a larger number means a larger wick. Across series the numbers do not compare. A 22 in one series is not necessarily bigger than an 8 in another.

How to read a wick chart

A wick chart cross references wax and diameter and gives a suggested wick. Treat it as the first candle in your test.

Charts are built under one set of fixed conditions, and your wax, dye, essential oils and scent load will not match them exactly. The picks are estimates, and your candle may need a different size. Scenting is covered in how to choose essential oils for candles.

The practical approach is to pour three testers. Use the chart's pick, one size below and one size above. If your vessel falls between two diameter bands, test the smaller size first.

A simple burn test

Run the same steps on every tester so the results can be compared.

  1. Cure. Let the candle cure at least 24 hours before testing. Keep the cure time the same for every tester.
  2. Trim. Trim a cotton wick to 1/4 inch (6 mm) before every lighting.
  3. Burn in timed cycles. Place testers on a flat, heat resistant surface away from drafts, 3 to 6 inches (8 to 15 cm) apart. Check them every hour, extinguish after four hours, and never leave them unattended.
  4. Cool and repeat. Let the candle cool at least five hours, then trim and burn again. Continue until about 1/4 inch (6 mm) of wax remains.
  5. Judge late. Melt pools form slowly in the first burns. Wait until at least the fourth cycle before deciding.

What to look for

Observation What it suggests What to do
Ring of unmelted wax still on the wall after the fourth cycle, or a tunnel down the center Wick too small Size up
Melt pool deeper than the target, tall or constantly flickering flame Wick too large Size down
Large carbon caps (mushrooming) that drop into the wax Wick too large Size down
Frequent smoke, or soot on the glass Wick too large, or too much scent Size down, or lower the scent load
  • Melt pool. Look for a pool that comes within 1/4 inch (6 mm) of the wall after three to four hours. The usual target depth is 1/4 to 1/2 inch (6 to 13 mm), and some makers allow up to 3/4 inch (19 mm).
  • Coconut blends. Makers take two approaches to soft coconut waxes. Some avoid a full melt pool in the first few burns of a coconut heavy blend. Others accept a thin ring of wax on the wall early on, because in a soft blend that wax tends to slide down as the candle burns.
  • Flame. About 1 inch (2.5 cm) is typical. Some mushrooming and an occasional puff of soot are normal with CD and ECO wicks.

Change one size at a time, and start a fresh candle for each wick.

Double wicking wide vessels

Past a certain width, one wick large enough to reach the wall produces too much flame, and two or more smaller wicks do the job better. There is no fixed diameter where that happens. If the largest single wick that keeps a steady, modest flame still leaves wax on the wall, move to two.

A common way to pick the first wicks to test is to divide the diameter by the number of wicks and choose a wick rated for that smaller width. A 4 inch (10 cm) vessel with two wicks starts with wicks sized for 2 inches (5 cm). Space the wicks evenly from each other and from the wall, since wicks set too close to the edge can overheat the vessel.

Keep records

Label every tester with the wax, essential oils and scent load, dye, wick series and size, and the vessel with its inside diameter. Note what you see at each hourly check and take photos.

Natural waxes vary from batch to batch, so retest a finished line from time to time, and whenever you open a new lot of wax or change essential oils.

Wicks are coming to the store, and they will be listed under wicks when they arrive. In the meantime, the pouring steps are in how to make a coconut wax candle.