Container Candles vs Free Standing Candles: Which Should You Make?

White pillar candles and a dark jar candle burning on a window sill beside a green bouquet

Every candle is either poured into a vessel and burned there, or made to hold its own shape while it burns. That one difference decides which wax you buy, how you wick it and how much scent the finished candle gives off. This guide explains both types, the natural waxes that suit each, and which one to make first.

What each type is

A container candle is made and burned in the same vessel. Jars and tins are the familiar examples. Most scented candles are container candles.

A free standing candle holds its shape with no vessel around it. Pillars, tapers, votives, tealights and molded shapes belong here.

We class tealights and votives as free standing candles because they do not need a container to burn. They are often burned in a holder, which keeps the melted wax together and helps them burn more efficiently.

For a maker the practical question is what the wax has to do. A candle that comes out of a mold and stands on its own needs a firm wax. A candle that stays in the vessel it was poured into can use a soft one.

What each type asks of the wax

A container wax never has to stand up by itself, because the vessel holds it. It can be soft and melt at a low temperature. What it does need is to cling to the vessel wall so no gaps show through the glass.

A free standing wax has the opposite job. It must be hard enough to stay rigid in a warm room and to keep its shape beside its own flame. It also has to come out of a mold cleanly. Wax contracts as it cools, and a wax that is firm and does not grip the mold wall lets go of it. Clinging, the property you want in a jar, is the property you do not want in a mold.

Natural waxes for containers

Soft, low melt plant waxes are container waxes. Our Creamy Coconut Wax (CCN1 by Calwax) is a coconut based blend that melts at 108 to 115°F (42 to 46°C), is soft and creamy, and adheres very well to glass. It holds a scent load of up to 10 percent. A wax this soft cannot stand as a pillar.

Natural waxes for free standing candles

Hard, high melt waxes are free standing waxes. Beeswax melts at 62 to 65°C (about 144 to 149°F).

Rice bran wax is harder and melts higher still. Our Premium Rice Bran Wax melts at 167 to 185°F (75 to 85°C) and our Rice Bran Wax Pastilles at 170.6 to 179.6°F (77 to 82°C). It is a hard plant based wax that is often compared with carnauba. Makers use it to raise the melt point and hardness of a blend. There is more in what is rice bran wax.

Our rice bran waxes melt at least 50°F (about 29°C) higher than our coconut wax. All three are in our wax collection.

Why container candles throw more scent

Scent leaves a burning candle mostly by evaporation from the pool of liquid wax around the wick. A 2021 chamber study of scented candles found that the scent compounds measured in the air had mostly evaporated from the molten wax pool. Scent that travels up the wick into the flame is largely burned.

Evaporation from a liquid surface follows two simple rules. The larger the exposed surface, the more evaporates. The warmer the liquid, the higher the vapor pressure of the volatile compounds in it, and the faster they leave. The two candle types build very different pools.

  • The container holds a full pool. In a jar the liquid wax has nowhere to go. A correctly wicked container candle melts from wall to wall, so the whole top of the candle becomes warm, scented liquid.
  • Low melt wax liquefies easily. A wax that melts at 108 to 115°F needs far less heat to turn liquid than one that melts above 167°F. The same flame keeps a wider, deeper pool in the softer wax.
  • The container holds heat. The vessel wall shelters the pool and keeps the wax at the edge liquid.
  • A free standing candle keeps its pool small on purpose. Makers wick a pillar to leave a wall of solid wax around the pool, because a pool that reached the edge would spill down the side. A taper holds only a small cup of liquid under the flame.

There is a second reason, and it starts before the candle is lit. Essential oils are volatile. To scent a hard wax you have to stir the oil into wax that is hot enough to be fully liquid. For rice bran wax that means 167°F or more, and for beeswax about 144°F or more. The hotter the wax, the more of the lighter scent compounds evaporate during making. A free standing candle also has to stay rigid, so makers generally keep its scent load lower than the 10 percent a container wax like ours can hold.

An essential oil scented pillar, taper or votive gives a light scent close to the candle. Its scent throw will not compare to a container candle made with the same essential oils. If scent is the point of the candle, make it a container candle.

Wicking

The wick is the pump that feeds liquid wax to the flame, and its size sets how much fuel the flame receives. The National Candle Association describes the main families. Flat braided wicks curl into the flame as they burn and are the usual choice for tapers and pillars. Square braided wicks are sturdier and are preferred for beeswax. Cored wicks have a stiff center that keeps them upright in a deep pool of liquid wax, which is why they are common in jars and votives.

The goal differs too. In a container you size the wick so the pool reaches the wall. In a pillar you size it so the pool stops short of the edge. The testing method is in how to choose a candle wick for natural wax.

Burn behavior and burn time

Burn time depends on how much wax the candle holds and how fast its wick consumes it, so neither type lasts longer by nature. The types do behave differently as they burn.

A container candle burns straight down inside its vessel and keeps its wax contained. A pillar burns down through its center and needs a heat resistant plate beneath it. A taper needs a holder to stay upright. A votive turns fully liquid in its holder.

The National Candle Association's guidance on when to stop also differs by type. It advises ending a free standing candle when 2 inches of wax remain and a container candle at 1/2 inch.

Molds and equipment

Both types need a scale, a thermometer, a pouring pitcher and a double boiler.

  • Container candles need vessels made for candles and something to center the wick while the wax sets. There is a published standard for glass candle containers that covers how the glass is annealed and how it handles thermal shock, so buy vessels sold for candle use.
  • Free standing candles need molds and a way to seal the wick hole. Hard waxes are worked at much higher temperatures, and because the wax contracts as it sets, the base often needs a second pour to level it. Tapers can also be dipped, which takes a tall pot of melted wax.

Packaging and shipping

A container candle ships in a breakable vessel that adds weight, so it needs padding and a sturdy box. Its wax is the other weak point. A wax that begins to melt at 108°F (42°C) can soften in summer transit, so store and ship these candles upright and cool.

A free standing candle is lighter and has no glass, and a wax that melts above 144°F tolerates far more heat. Every surface is on show, so wrap each candle to prevent scuffs and support tapers along their length.

Which to make first

Start with a container candle. The vessel does the structural work, a soft wax is forgiving to pour, and there is no unmolding step to go wrong. A container is also where essential oils perform best, which matters if you are making non-toxic, natural candles scented only with them. Our step by step method is in how to make a coconut wax candle.

Move to free standing candles when you want unscented or lightly scented pieces for the table, or when you want to sell a candle with no vessel at all. Begin with a simple pillar or votive mold in beeswax or a beeswax and rice bran wax blend, and expect a few trial batches.